AKC is a participant in affiliate advertising programs designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to akc.org. If you purchase a product through this article, we may receive a portion of the sale.
There are many tools that can help you with dog training such as clickers, treats, and a positive attitude. Dog whistles may not be as commonly used, but they’re another tool to help you communicate with your dog. They aren’t magic, but if you train your dog to associate a whistle with rewards, you can incorporate one into your training for many different behaviors.
Ever wondered if dog whistles are actually worth the hype? As someone who’s spent countless hours training my own furry companions, I’ve learned that dog whistles aren’t magical solutions—but they can be incredibly useful training tools when used correctly.
In this comprehensive guide, I’ll walk you through everything you need to know about dog whistles—from how they work to when (and when not) to use them Whether you’re a hunter needing long-distance communication with your retriever or simply trying to improve your pup’s recall at the dog park, this article will help you decide if a dog whistle is right for you.
What Exactly Is a Dog Whistle?
Many people immediately think of silent whistles that only dogs can hear, but that’s actually just one type. Most dog whistles create audible sounds that both you and your dog can hear clearly—similar to a referee’s whistle.
Dog whistles are simply whistles that produce high-pitched sounds. These higher frequencies are well-suited to dog ears because dogs can hear sounds as high as 45,000 Hz or higher, whereas adult humans can only hear sounds up to about 20,000 Hz. This means your dog can hear many sounds that you can’t, including the shriek of some dog whistles even from a considerable distance.
Are Dog Whistles Actually Good for Training?
The short answer Yes, dog whistles can be excellent training tools—but they’re not magic wands.
Dog whistles offer several distinct advantages
- Save your voice – After a long day of yelling commands, your voice gets hoarse. Puffing on a whistle is much less straining.
- Create unique sounds – There’s no mistaking the blow of a whistle. Your dog won’t confuse one command with another.
- Sound carries far – Even if your dog is running far away, the blast from a whistle can easily be heard. Good luck yelling that far!
- Work in any weather – The sound of a dog whistle is loud enough to overcome wind, rain, and crashing waves.
- Consistent cues – Unlike your voice, whistles don’t carry emotions and sound the same every time, making them great for dogs with multiple handlers.
However, there are two myths I need to bust:
-
Myth: Dog whistles stop barking – While the first few blows might distract your dog into silence, they’ll likely get used to the noise and bark right through it eventually.
-
Myth: Dog whistles make your dog come when called – There’s nothing about the whistle itself that tells your dog what to do. Like any cue (verbal or hand signal), you need to train your dog to respond accordingly.
Types of Dog Whistles: Finding What Works
There are two main types of dog whistles, each with their own advantages:
1. Audible Dog Whistles
These traditional whistles produce sounds both you and your dog can hear. They come in two varieties:
-
With Pea (or Pearl): These have a small ball inside that allows for more sound variations like trills. This can be helpful if you want different commands for different sounds. However, the pea can freeze in cold weather, making the whistle useless.
-
Pealess: These don’t have a ball inside, resulting in a considerably louder sound that can sometimes be heard from two miles away! The tone remains constant regardless of how hard you blow, which is perfect for consistent training.
2. Silent or Ultrasonic Dog Whistles
These whistles use higher “ultrasonic” frequencies that are loud and easy for dogs to hear but quieter for humans. Remember that most silent whistles aren’t entirely silent—you may still hear a quiet sound like air escaping from a tire.
Silent whistles are better for:
- Using in dog parks or public places
- Training easily startled dogs
- Not annoying your neighbors
However, they don’t carry as well over long distances or in windy conditions.
How to Choose the Right Dog Whistle
The frequency that works best varies between dogs. Some dogs respond better to lower frequencies, while others prefer higher ones. When choosing a dog whistle, consider:
- Your training environment – Need long-distance communication? Go for a louder pealess whistle. Training at home? A silent whistle might be better.
- Your dog’s temperament – Easily startled dogs might do better with silent whistles.
- Weather conditions – If you’ll be training in cold weather, avoid pea whistles which can freeze.
- Your preferences – Do you want to hear the whistle yourself? Choose an audible whistle.
Top Dog Whistles Worth Considering
Based on extensive testing, here are some of the best dog whistles available:
-
Acme 535 Silent Dog Whistle – Best silent whistle with adjustable frequency between 5,800Hz and 12,400Hz. Great for training in open fields or populated areas.
-
SportDOG Brand Roy Gonia Special Whistle – Best audible whistle with pea. Popular for retriever training with a lower-pitched trill sound that carries well.
-
Acme 212 Dog Training Whistle – Best pealess audible whistle. Holds the same medium-pitch frequency regardless of how hard you blow, making it excellent for recall.
-
All Weather Storm Safety Whistle – Extremely loud whistle that can be heard from miles away. Perfect for large properties or rural areas.
-
Fox 40 CMG Mini Whistle – Compact, loud pealess whistle that produces 115 decibels of high-pitched sound dogs can hear up to a mile away. Great for hiking and outdoor activities.
-
Coachi Whizzclick 2-in-1 – Combines a whistle and clicker for versatile training options.
When Should You Use a Dog Whistle?
Dog whistles are particularly useful for:
- Recall training – Getting your dog to come back to you
- Distance training – Working with your dog from far away
- Stay commands – Teaching your dog to remain in place
- Hunting and herding – Communicating with working dogs
- Noisy environments – Being heard over background noise
Rachel Lane, a dog trainer and certified behavior consultant, uses dog whistles primarily for recall behaviors. She also finds whistles great for teaching a stay-where-you-are behavior, which is helpful when working with dogs at a distance in dog sports or hunting.
When NOT to Use a Dog Whistle
There are situations where using a dog whistle could be inappropriate or even harmful:
- When there’s a risk of triggering aggression in dogs or other animals
- In environments with loud noises like construction sites or busy streets that could startle your dog
- If your dog is already distressed or anxious – address the cause rather than relying on the whistle
- During emergencies requiring immediate attention
- In areas with noise regulations or close neighbors who might be disturbed
How to Whistle Train Your Dog: A Step-by-Step Guide
-
Ensure verbal commands are mastered first – Your dog should respond quickly and correctly to voice commands before introducing the whistle.
-
Choose your whistle frequency – If using an adjustable silent whistle, test it while your dog is sleeping. If they wake up, it’s a good indication they’ll respond to it.
-
Start in a distraction-free environment like your home or yard.
-
Begin by saying the verbal command, using your chosen whistle sound, then repeating the verbal command – When your dog responds correctly, reward them with praise and treats.
-
Repeat as needed, gradually phasing out the verbal command – Work on one command at a time.
-
Be consistent with your whistle patterns – For example, many trainers use one blast for “sit” and three blasts for “come” or “here.”
Safety Tips for Using Dog Whistles
To protect your dog’s well-being:
- Keep the volume at a safe level for your dog’s hearing
- Never blow the whistle close to their ears to prevent discomfort
- Use the whistle in a controlled environment to minimize risks
- Monitor your dog’s behavior for signs of distress during training
- Gradually introduce the whistle with positive reinforcement
Common Mistakes to Avoid
When using a dog whistle, avoid these pitfalls:
- Using a whistle without proper training – it won’t be effective
- Repeatedly blowing when your dog isn’t listening – this teaches them to ignore it
- Switching whistles without retraining – dogs learn to recognize specific whistles
- Changing frequencies – consistency is key
- Inconsistent use – your dog will forget their training if you don’t practice regularly
Is a Dog Whistle Right for You?
Dog whistles aren’t necessary for every dog owner. Their effectiveness varies depending on each dog’s temperament and characteristics. Consider your specific training needs and your dog’s personality before investing in one.
If you have close neighbors, train in public spaces, or have a noise-sensitive dog, a silent whistle might be best. For hunting, herding, or training in open areas, an audible whistle typically works better.
Alternatives to Dog Whistles
If you decide a dog whistle isn’t right for you, consider these alternatives:
- Clicker training – Uses the sound of a clicking device to mark and reinforce positive behavior
- Hand signals – Visual cues that can be used alongside or instead of verbal commands
- Treat-based positive reinforcement – Motivates dogs to comply with commands
- Vibrating collars – Provide a physical sensation rather than a sound
Final Thoughts: Are Dog Whistles Good?
Dog whistles can be extremely effective training tools when used properly. They’re not magic solutions that automatically fix behavior problems, but rather communication devices that require proper training and consistent use.
I’ve found them particularly useful for recall training with my own dogs, especially in outdoor environments where my voice just doesn’t carry far enough. The consistency of the sound and the ability to be heard at a distance makes whistles invaluable for many training scenarios.
Whether a dog whistle is “good” ultimately depends on your specific needs, your dog’s temperament, and how well you train with it. Like any training tool, success comes down to consistency, patience, and positive reinforcement.
Have you tried using a dog whistle with your four-legged friend? What was your experience like? I’d love to hear about it in the comments below!
Are There Different Types of Dog Whistles?
Dog whistles come in a range of frequencies and types, and Lane advises her clients to choose whichever one they like. It’s worth experimenting to find the version your dog responds to best and what you feel most comfortable using. In Psychology Today, Dr. Stanley Coren said a small dog might respond well to a higher pitch whereas a larger dog might not. He also said a dog who seems to have lost their sense of hearing may respond to certain high-pitched sounds if they haven’t lost their hearing in that higher range, so whistles are worth a try even with deaf dogs.
The typical dog whistle makes a single pitch when blown. But there are also two-tone dog whistles that produce two different pitches you can choose between. This can be handy if you want to work with two dogs as you can assign each dog a different sound. Alternatively, you can train each tone as a cue for a different behavior. There are also dog whistles that allow for a whole range of sounds. Also known as a shepherd’s lip whistle, these require more practice to get the tone where you want it, but are popular in the herding world. There are also dog whistles with peas (a small ball that vibrates inside the whistle when you blow) that are better for cold conditions as the whistle won’t freeze. You can even get a dog whistle/clicker combination tool.
Finally, you need to decide if you want to hear the whistle or not. Some whistles are within the audible range for humans and others are silent. However, a better term is ultrasonic as these silent dog whistles still make a sound. It’s just one too high for human hearing. Ultrasonic whistles won’t bother your neighbors or housemates, but as you can’t hear it, you might not feel as comfortable using it for multiple cues such as three toots for a recall and a long toot for a sit.
How Do Dog Whistles Work?
Dog whistles are simply whistles that produce a high-pitched sound. These higher frequencies are well suited to dog ears because dogs can hear sounds as high-pitched as 45,000 Hz or higher, whereas adult humans can only hear sounds as high-pitched as 20,000 Hz. That means there are many sounds your dog can hear that you can’t, and the shriek of a dog whistle will be clearly audible to your dog even at a distance.
But how do these special whistles work? First, there are two myths to bust. One is that the high sound can stop a dog from barking. Although the first few blows may distract your dog into silence, they will likely acclimatize to the noise and bark right through it. The second myth is that dog whistles make your dog come when called. However, there is nothing about the whistle itself that tells your dog what to do. Whistles are just another cue like a word or hand signal. You need to train your dog to respond accordingly.
Rachel Lane, dog trainer, certified behavior consultant, and owner of Leash & Learn, uses dog whistles as a cue for the recall behavior. “I incorporate whistles into my training program because of the many distinct advantages that they provide. Most importantly, it is an effective tool for communication and makes it easier for handlers to teach their dog to come to them reliably, the first time they hear the whistle, and every time they hear the whistle.”
Former Army Interrogator points out lies and dog whistles at Charlie Kirk presser
FAQ
Do dog whistles actually work?
Yes, dog whistles do work, but not on their own; they rely on a proper training process where a dog learns to associate the whistle’s sound with a specific command or reward. Dog whistles work because they operate at a higher frequency than most humans can hear, allowing them to cut through background noise, travel further, and communicate effectively over long distances without startling people. To be effective, a whistle must be used consistently, with proper volume, and in a controlled environment with positive reinforcement to build the dog’s understanding of the cue.
What are the disadvantages of a dog whistle?
Potential Risks and Misuses of Dog Whistles
Overusing the whistle might result in dogs becoming desensitised to its sound, thereby reducing its effectiveness. Whistle commands should always be complemented by reinforcement techniques in order to encourage desired behaviour.
Do dog whistles scare dogs away?
A deterrent can be anything from a dog treat to a spray and is easily carried on the body. Some deterrents include: Whistle with a sharp note or ultrasonic: Dogs have sensitive hearing and a whistle with a sharp or ultrasonic tone can be effective in shutting down a dog that’s engaging in aggressive behavior.
How far away can a dog hear a dog whistle?