Are Retractable Leashes Good for Small Dogs? The Truth You Need to Know

Ever watched your tiny fluffball zig-zagging around the park and wondered if that fancy retractable leash is really the best choice? You’re not alone! As a small dog owner myself, I’ve gone through the whole leash dilemma and spent countless hours researching what actually works best for our little four-legged friends.

Retractable leashes seem like the perfect solution – they give your pup freedom while keeping them “controlled,” But are they really good for small dogs? The answer isn’t as straightforward as you might think

The Appeal of Retractable Leashes for Small Dogs

Let’s be honest – there’s something attractive about retractable leashes, especially when you have a curious little explorer on your hands. Here’s why many small dog owners consider them:

• Freedom to explore: Your little pup can wander up to 16 feet away to sniff and investigate while you maintain control
• Adjustable length: You can give more or less leash depending on the situation
• Convenience: The automatic retracting feature means less tangling (in theory)
• Feeling of freedom: Small dogs especially enjoy the ability to roam a bit more

When I first got my Yorkie, I immediately purchased a retractable leash thinking it would be perfect for our walks The idea of giving her more freedom while still keeping her safe seemed like a no-brainer!

The Reality: 7 Serious Concerns About Retractable Leashes

Despite their popularity retractable leashes come with significant risks that every small dog owner should consider

1. Injury Risks Are Real

The thin cord on retractable leashes can cause serious injuries. If your small dog suddenly darts after a squirrel and you grab the cord to stop them, you could get a nasty rope burn or even a cut. Worse yet, if the leash locks while your dog is running, the sudden stop could cause neck or throat injuries – especially concerning for small dogs with delicate tracheas.

2. Mechanical Failures Happen Often

The internal mechanism in retractable leashes can jam or break unexpectedly. When this happens, you might lose control of your dog completely. For small dogs who could easily slip through traffic or become prey for larger animals, this is particularly dangerous.

One time my friend’s retractable leash jammed while walking her Chihuahua near a busy street. Scary moment! The plastic handle also cracked after dropping it just once.

3. Tangling Troubles

Despite being designed to prevent tangling, retractable leashes often create more tangling problems. When your small dog runs around another dog or person, the thin cord can wrap around legs, causing falls or injuries. Since small dogs are quick and agile, they can create a tangling disaster in seconds!

4. Nearly Invisible Cords

The thin cord on most retractable leashes is difficult to see. This creates a tripping hazard for both you and others. People can easily trip over the extended cord, potentially injuring themselves or causing your small dog to panic.

5. Easy to Drop, Hard to Recover

The bulky plastic handles are surprisingly easy to drop, especially if your small dog suddenly lunges. When dropped, the noise often scares small dogs, causing them to bolt while dragging the heavy handle behind them. My Yorkie once got spooked by the sound and ran nearly a block before I could catch her!

6. Terrible for Anxious or Fearful Dogs

Many small dogs tend to be more cautious or anxious by nature. If they get tangled in a retractable leash or are frightened by the sound of a dropped handle, they may panic. This can lead to increased anxiety around walks or even cause them to slip out of their collar in fear.

7. Reinforces Pulling Behavior

Perhaps most concerning for long-term training, retractable leashes actually teach your small dog to pull. When they pull and you release more line, you’re reinforcing that pulling gets them what they want – more freedom. This creates a frustrating cycle that makes proper leash training nearly impossible.

Top 5 Retractable Leashes for Small Dogs (If You Still Want One)

Despite the concerns, if you’re still considering a retractable leash for specific situations, here are the top-rated options for small dogs:

1. FLEXI New Classic Cord Retractable Dog Leash

Rating: 8.7/10

This German-made leash is designed for dogs up to 26 lbs and extends to 16 feet. Its quality construction and reliable brake system make it a safer option among retractable leashes.

Pros:

• German engineering and quality
• Strong cord for better control
• Multiple sizes available
• Easy-to-use brake system
• Tangle-free design

Cons:

• Only suitable for small dogs
• Cord may break if chewed

2. Fida Retractable Dog Leash

Rating: 8.8/10

Designed for dogs up to 26 lbs with a 16-foot extension, this leash features reflective materials for night safety and a comfortable handle.

Pros:

• Durable construction
• Reflective tape for nighttime safety
• Soft, ergonomic handle
• Simple lock/unlock mechanism
• 30-day money-back guarantee

Cons:

• Weight limitation of 26 lbs
• Not suitable for larger dogs

3. TUG 360° Tangle-Free Retractable Dog Leash

Rating: 9.0/10

This highly-rated option features a 16-foot nylon tape and one-handed brake system. The small size works for dogs under 35 lbs.

Pros:

• True 360-degree tangle-free design
• User-friendly lock/unlock feature
• Comfortable anti-slip handle
• Reliable internal coil
• Easy thumb control

Cons:

• Not suitable for dogs who chew leashes
• Can malfunction with heavy pulling

4. enrgticdg 16Ft Retractable Dog Leash

Rating: 8.6/10

This lightweight option is suitable for small to medium dogs up to 50 pounds with a 16-foot extension.

Pros:

• Simple lock/unlock system
• 360-degree tangle-free movement
• Ample 16-foot exploration range
• Ergonomic handle for comfort

Cons:

• Can break if chewed
• Spring may damage if fully extended when dog lunges

5. LIEVUIKEN Retractable Dog Leash

Rating: 8.8/10

Available in 10 or 16-foot options, this leash works for small dogs up to 22 pounds with an easy-to-use design.

Pros:

• Smooth extension and retraction
• Durable rope construction
• Comfortable non-slip handle
• Safe materials
• Easy-to-use brake buttons
• Versatile for various activities

Cons:

• Keep your dog in sight at all times

Better Alternatives for Walking Small Dogs

After trying numerous options with my own small dogs, I’ve found these alternatives to be much safer and more effective:

1. Standard 4-6 Foot Leashes

A good quality, fixed-length leash made of nylon or neoprene provides better control and safety. For urban walks, a 4-6 foot leash keeps your small dog close enough to protect them while still allowing some freedom.

2. Long Training Lines

For open spaces like parks or beaches, a long training line (10-30 feet) offers freedom similar to retractable leashes but with better control and fewer mechanical risks. These flat leashes are easier to grip if needed and don’t have mechanical parts that can fail.

3. Harnesses Instead of Collars

Regardless of leash type, small dogs benefit greatly from wearing harnesses instead of collars. This distributes pressure across their chest rather than their delicate necks, reducing injury risk if they suddenly lunge or pull.

Making the Right Choice for Your Small Dog

The best leash ultimately depends on your specific situation and your dog’s temperament. Consider these factors:

• Your dog’s training level: Well-trained dogs who don’t pull may handle retractable leashes better
• Walking location: Urban environments require more control than open spaces
• Your dog’s personality: Anxious or easily startled dogs do better with standard leashes
• Physical limitations: Consider your ability to control your dog if they suddenly lunge

My Personal Experience

I’ve tried all types of leashes with my small dogs over the years. While retractable leashes seemed convenient at first, I eventually switched to standard leashes for daily walks and long training lines for park visits.

One time, my Maltese got tangled in a retractable leash and panicked, nearly slipping out of her collar near a busy street. That was the moment I decided the risks weren’t worth the perceived benefits. Since switching to standard leashes, our walks have been more relaxed and controlled, and her leash manners have improved significantly.

Final Thoughts: Are Retractable Leashes Good for Small Dogs?

While retractable leashes offer the allure of freedom, the safety concerns and training issues they present make them problematic for most small dogs. The risks of injury, mechanical failure, and reinforced pulling behavior often outweigh the benefits.

For most small dog owners, I recommend:

1. A high-quality 4-6 foot standard leash for daily walks
2. A properly fitted harness instead of a collar
3. A long training line for occasional use in open, safe areas

Remember, the best walks happen when both you and your furry friend feel safe and comfortable. Sometimes the simplest tools are the most effective!

Have you tried retractable leashes with your small dog? What was your experience? I’d love to hear your thoughts in the comments below!

Vets dislike retractable leashes due to the high risk of injuries to both dogs and people, including cuts, burns, and even amputations from the thin cord, and severe neck and spinal injuries for dogs from sudden jerks. These leashes also provide less control, can break easily, reinforce pulling behavior, and make it easier for dogs to encounter dangerous situations like traffic or other dogs, leading to more emergency visits.