As more pet owners adopt vegan lifestyles for environmental, ethical, and health reasons, many wonder if their furry companions can join them on this journey. Is it possible for dogs and cats to thrive on plant-based diets? This question has sparked debates among veterinarians, pet nutritionists, and animal lovers alike.
In this article, I’ll dive deep into what science and veterinary experts say about vegan diets for our pets, examining the key differences between dogs and cats, and providing practical advice for those considering this dietary change.
Dogs vs. Cats: Different Digestive Systems, Different Needs
Before discussing vegan diets for pets, it’s crucial to understand the fundamental differences between dogs and cats:
Dogs: Adaptable Omnivores
Dogs evolved alongside humans for thousands of years and adapted to eat a variety of foods. They’re considered omnivores, meaning they can derive nutrients from both plant and animal sources. Their digestive systems have developed some ability to process starches and plant materials, though their natural diet would include meat.
Cats: Obligate Carnivores
Cats, on the other hand, are obligate carnivores. This means their bodies have evolved specifically to require nutrients found almost exclusively in animal tissues. Their digestive systems are specialized for processing meat, and they lack certain enzymes needed to efficiently process plant materials.
Can Dogs Thrive on a Vegan Diet?
The answer is more nuanced than a simple yes or no.
What Research Shows
Recent research, including a study published in PLOS ONE by Andrew Knight from the University of Winchester suggests that dogs on carefully planned vegan diets might actually experience health benefits compared to those on conventional meat-based diets.
The survey which included guardians of 2536 dogs, found that
- Dogs on conventional diets were generally less healthy than those on raw meat or vegan diets
- Dogs on raw meat diets appeared healthier than those on vegan diets in some metrics, though this could be due to factors like age differences and veterinary visit frequency
- Nutritionally complete vegan diets might be a safer and potentially healthier option for dogs when properly formulated
Nutritional Considerations for Dogs
If considering a vegan diet for your dog, these nutrients require special attention:
- Protein: Dogs need complete proteins containing all essential amino acids
- Taurine and L-carnitine: Important for heart and muscle function
- Vitamin D3: Dogs cannot synthesize this from sunlight like humans
- Omega fatty acids: Critical for skin, coat, and brain health
Commercial Vegan Dog Foods
Several companies now produce nutritionally balanced vegan dog foods that include synthetic versions of nutrients typically found in meat. These include brands like:
- V-Dog
- Wild Earth
- BIOpet Vegan
- Royal Canin Vegetarian
- Purina ProPlan HA Vegetarian
These formulations typically undergo AAFCO (Association of American Feed Control Officials) testing to ensure nutritional adequacy.
Can Cats Be Vegan? The Bigger Challenge
The consensus among veterinary professionals is much clearer when it comes to cats.
The Obligate Carnivore Challenge
As obligate carnivores, cats have strict nutritional requirements that are difficult to meet with plant-based diets alone. Several critical nutrients are either absent in plant foods or present in forms cats cannot efficiently utilize:
- Taurine: Essential for heart function, vision, and reproduction
- Vitamin A: Cats cannot convert beta-carotene from plants into vitamin A
- Arachidonic acid: An essential fatty acid not found in plant foods
- Vitamin D3: Required for calcium regulation and bone health
- Complete proteins: Cats need specific amino acid profiles
The lack of these nutrients can lead to serious health problems over time, including:
- Dilated cardiomyopathy (heart disease)
- Vision problems
- Reproductive issues
- Weakened immune system
- Poor growth in kittens
Expert Opinions
Small Door Veterinary explicitly states: “Cats cannot be fed a vegetarian or vegan diet. They are obligate carnivores, which means they simply cannot get the nutrients they need (like taurine) from plants, and so they must eat meat or fish and not too many carbohydrates.”
The British Veterinary Association echoes these concerns, emphasizing that while dogs might adapt to plant-based diets, the same cannot be confidently said for cats.
Risks of Inappropriate Vegan Diets for Pets
Feeding an improperly formulated vegan diet to your pet can lead to several health problems:
For Dogs:
- Protein deficiency
- Amino acid imbalances
- Vitamin and mineral deficiencies
- Poor coat condition
- Reduced energy
For Cats (even more serious):
- Taurine deficiency leading to heart disease
- Vision problems
- Reproductive issues
- Developmental problems in kittens
- Lethargy and muscle weakness
Practical Advice for Pet Owners Considering Vegan Diets
If you’re still considering a plant-based diet for your pet, here are some important steps to take:
For Dog Owners:
-
Consult your veterinarian first: Discuss your dog’s specific health needs and whether a vegan diet might be appropriate.
-
Choose commercially prepared foods: Look for AAFCO-approved vegan dog foods rather than attempting to create homemade recipes.
-
Transition slowly: Gradually introduce the new diet over 7-10 days to avoid digestive upset.
-
Monitor health closely: Watch for changes in energy, coat quality, weight, and overall wellbeing.
-
Schedule regular check-ups: More frequent veterinary visits (at least twice yearly) are recommended to monitor nutrient levels and overall health.
-
Consider supplements: Your vet may recommend specific supplements to ensure complete nutrition.
For Cat Owners:
The consensus among veterinary professionals is that cats should not be fed a vegan diet. If you’re concerned about the environmental or ethical impact of your cat’s diet, consider these alternatives:
-
Look for sustainably sourced pet foods: Some companies focus on using more sustainable animal proteins.
-
Consider insect-based cat foods: These provide the necessary animal proteins with a lower environmental footprint.
-
Focus on quality over quantity: Higher-quality meat-based foods may allow you to feed smaller amounts.
My Personal Take
As someone deeply interested in both animal welfare and pet health, I understand the ethical dilemma vegan pet owners face. While I believe dogs can potentially thrive on a well-planned vegan diet with proper supplementation and monitoring, I’m not convinced cats can safely follow suit.
For my own pets, I’ve chosen to prioritize their biological needs while making environmentally conscious choices where possible. This includes selecting pet foods with sustainably sourced ingredients and incorporating some plant foods for my dog where appropriate.
Balancing Ethics and Biology
It’s important to remember that our pets didn’t choose veganism—we did. While we make dietary choices based on our values, our pets rely on us to meet their biological needs.
Dr. Andrew Jones notes, “While raw or homemade animal protein diets seem ideal, rising food costs and economic constraints make vegan dog food a viable, if not perfect, option for many.” This pragmatic approach acknowledges both the ethical considerations and practical realities of pet care.
So, can dogs and cats be vegan? The evidence suggests:
-
Dogs: Yes, potentially, with careful planning, proper supplementation, and regular veterinary monitoring. Commercial vegan dog foods that meet AAFCO standards can provide complete nutrition.
-
Cats: No, not recommended. As obligate carnivores, cats require nutrients found almost exclusively in animal tissues. Even with supplements, vegan diets pose significant health risks for cats.
Whatever dietary path you choose for your pet, regular veterinary check-ups and blood work are essential to ensure they’re receiving proper nutrition. Our pets’ health and wellbeing should always be the primary consideration when making these important decisions.
Remember, each pet is an individual with unique needs, and what works for one animal may not work for another. When in doubt, consult with a veterinary nutritionist who can provide personalized guidance for your furry friend.
What’s your experience with alternative diets for pets? Have you tried plant-based options for your dog? I’d love to hear your thoughts and experiences in the comments below!
Materials and Methods
Inclusive criteria were as follows: (P—population) studies that included dogs (Canis familiaris) or cats (Felis catus) in a domestic setting (construed broadly to include working dogs, as well as companion and laboratory animals). Studies evaluating animals of any breed, age or sex were eligible for inclusion; (I—intervention) studies where the animals had been fed a vegetarian or vegan diet (the latter containing no animal products—see definition below); (C—comparator) studies were included that compared the animals being fed meat-free diets, with those animals fed any kind of standard meat-based diets, or those studies without any parallel control group for comparison, e.g., within subjects comparison (pre-post diet change) or case-series design; (O—outcomes) outcomes had to be an animal-based measure that was related to animal health, physiology, or welfare. This could be a proxy report by the animal carer, in addition to those measures that could be measured directly upon animal examination; (S—study design) experimental and quasi-experimental study designs including randomized controlled trials, non-randomized controlled trials, and before-and-after studies were eligible for inclusion. Observational studies and case studies were also eligible for inclusion with critique related to study design being provided below in the results and discussion. This study is reported in accordance with PRISMA guidance [21].
The search strategy aimed to locate published studies written in English and Spanish (the languages spoken by the authors). An initial limited search of Medline via Pubmed was undertaken to identify articles on the topic and any MeSH terms. The text words contained in the titles, abstracts, and index terms were used to develop a full search strategy for Medline. The search strategy was then adapted for the Scopus and Web of Science (including CAB Abstracts) databases. Key concepts were: “cat”, “dog”, “meat-free diet”, “vegan” “vegetarian”, “plant-based” and “health”. Grey literature, such as theses, sourced through these databases were eligible for inclusion. Reference lists of all studies selected for critical appraisal were screened for additional studies. The three databases were searched in October 2022 using the advanced search strategy derived (see Appendix A). There were no date restrictions on study selection, provided the studies were accessible through the three listed databases.
Following the search, all identified citations were collated and uploaded into Covidence (Veritas Health Innovation, Melbourne, Australia), and duplicates were removed. Titles and abstracts were screened by two reviewers (A.W. and A.O.) for assessment against the inclusion criteria for the review. Full text screening was similarly performed by two independent reviewers.
Any failures of consensus that arose between the reviewers at each stage of the study selection process were resolved though discussion, with a third reviewer (I.S.) being consulted if an extra opinion was required.
4. Assessment of Methodological Quality
Eligible studies were critically appraised for methodological quality using standard reporting guidelines/critical appraisal tools: a modified version of the SYRCLE risk of bias [22] assessment for randomized control studies, the STROBE-Vet statement for observational study designs (version adapted for veterinary studies) [23], and the JBI critical appraisal checklists for case reports (not veterinary specific) [24]. Survey studies were not critically appraised, since there are no published guidelines for doing this in studies of a veterinary nature which typically use animal guardians as respondents. This assessment was performed by two independent reviewers (A.W. and A.O.) using the quality assessment template created for these criteria in Covidence. Any disagreements that arose were resolved through discussion. All articles, regardless of the results of their methodological quality, underwent data extraction and synthesis. Consideration of the methodological quality of individual studies is discussed in the narrative synthesis.
Data were extracted from included studies by three independent reviewers (A.W., A.O., and I.S.) with each study being extracted by two reviewers using a modified version of the Covidence 2.0 extraction template. Extracted data included specific details about the populations sampled, the study design, diets considered, and the outcomes relevant to health measured with the time-course of assessment relative to diet introduction. Any disagreements that arose were resolved through discussion.
Data were synthesized based on two subgroups: (1) species (dogs and cat studies) (2) direct assessment of measure of health versus guardian report, i.e., proxy measure. Within these subgroups, studies were categorized based on similarity in the nature of the outcomes measured. Due to the heterogenous nature of the studies, as well the limited number, it was decided by the review team that a meta-analysis was not appropriate for any data included in this review. There were generally few studies within the relevant subgroups and there was often a lack of a control group to compute the effect size. Clinical heterogeneity existed between studies in terms of the outcomes measured and the time since the introduction of the diet. As a result, the data are presented narratively in the form of tables and text.
Within the veterinary literature, various terms have been used for plant-based diets and these are sometimes used without definition. This includes the terms vegan, vegetarian, meat-free and plant-based. Vegan diets are generally thought to refer to a complete absence of animal-based products in the diet (e.g., no egg or milk products), whilst vegetarian diets are normally considered to mean an absence of meat in the diet. For consistency, we have preferred to use the terminology “vegan diet” in this review to mean a complete absence of animal-based products but have reported the terminology used by authors of included studies in presenting our results. It is possible that these authors have not applied the terminology in the same way we have.
New Study on Vegan Diets for Cats and Dogs
FAQ
Can dogs and cats survive on a vegan diet?
Many (but not all) dogs and cats do well on a vegan diet, so watch them closely to ensure that the new food agrees with them.
Is it possible for a dog to be vegan?
Yes, dogs can technically be vegan, as they are omnivores and can derive nutrients from plants, but this requires careful planning and supplementation under professional supervision to ensure they receive all essential nutrients like taurine, vitamin D, and balanced protein. A veterinarian or veterinary nutritionist must be consulted to create a nutritionally complete vegan diet to prevent deficiencies, such as dilated cardiomyopathy from taurine deficiency or weakened bones from vitamin D deficiency.
Can a cat be a vegan?
No, cats should not be fed a vegan diet because they are obligate carnivores with specific nutritional needs—such as taurine, Vitamin A, and arachidonic acid—that are found naturally only in animal tissues and are essential for their survival. While some studies suggest that properly formulated vegan diets can provide these necessary nutrients, leading to comparable health outcomes to meat-based diets, many veterinarians and organizations advise against them due to concerns about ingredient bioavailability and potential risks to the cat’s health.
Does Peta think dogs should be vegan?
Many commercial meat-based dog foods can cause health problems in our animal companions. The nutritional needs of many dogs and cats can be met with a balanced vegan diet and certain supplements.