We’re back at it again, baby. This time, we tried out wet dog food. Oh, what joy. For those of y’all who missed the prequel to this culinary journey, we tried out five brands of wet cat food in this article, and we’re doing the same with five wet dog foods.
Like before, we’re judging these pet yum yums mainly by their smell and flavor, but things like texture, appearance, and price point come into play as well. Having tasted the cat food, we (namely me, our editor, and one of our video persons) were apprehensive about the dog food, but can you really blame us? Only one of the cat foods was even remotely tasty, and one of them tasted like a sardine smoothie. Blegh.
We tore open the first packet of dog food expecting it to be ruff, and… it wasn’t bad at all.
Ever wondered what your furry friend’s kibble actually tastes like? I’ve definitely caught myself staring at my dog Charlie as he enthusiastically chomps down his dinner thinking “is that stuff actually good?” You’re not alone in this curiosity – many pet parents wonder about the mysterious flavors hiding in those little brown nuggets.
The Short Answer
Dog food tastes completely different to dogs than it does to humans. This is because dogs have only about 1,700 taste buds compared to our 9,000. So while we might find kibble bland or even unpleasant, dogs are usually attracted to the meaty, savory flavors packed into their food.
My Personal Taste Test Experience
I’ll admit it – curiosity got the better of me once. After watching my pup devour his dinner with such enthusiasm, I decided to try a small piece of his premium kibble. Let’s just say… it wasn’t a culinary delight from a human perspective! It tasted bland with a slightly bitter aftertaste and had a weird gritty texture. But Charlie absolutely loves it, which is what matters.
Dog Food Flavors: What’s Actually in That Kibble?
Today’s pet food market offers a huge variety of flavors. From chicken to beef, salmon to lamb – there’s something for every doggy preference. These flavors come from a combination of:
- Real meat ingredients
- Vegetables and grains
- Vitamins and minerals
- Flavor enhancers (more on these later)
The interesting thing is that most dogs don’t experience flavor with the same complexity we do. They’re more attracted to the aroma and the basic taste profiles rather than subtle flavor notes
How Dog Food Tastes to Humans vs. Dogs
For us humans with our sensitive palates, dog food typically tastes:
- Bland or sometimes slightly bitter
- Gritty or chalky in texture
- Generally unappetizing
But for dogs, it’s a whole different experience. They have fewer taste buds and a different palate altogether. Dogs can taste:
- Sweet
- Sour
- Salty
- Bitter
- And “umami” (savory)
They’re particularly drawn to umami, which explains why meaty flavors are so popular in dog foods. While we might turn our noses up at kibble, our dogs find these flavors quite appealing!
Ingredients That Make Dog Food Taste Good (Or Bad)
The quality of ingredients plays a huge role in how dog food tastes. Here’s what tends to make dog food more appealing:
The Good Stuff:
- High-quality, real meat (chicken, beef, fish)
- Natural vegetables and grains
- Healthy fats and oils
The Not-So-Good Stuff:
- Low-quality meat by-products
- Excessive fillers (like corn and wheat)
- Artificial flavors and preservatives
I remember when I switched Charlie from a budget brand to a premium kibble with real chicken as the first ingredient. His excitement at mealtime doubled almost instantly! The difference in quality was obvious even to him.
How Processing Methods Impact Taste
The way dog food is processed significantly affects its flavor profile. Here are the main methods:
-
Extrusion – The most common method for dry kibble Ingredients are cooked under high pressure and forced through an extruder, This creates consistent texture but can sometimes diminish natural flavors,
-
Baking – Some premium dog foods are baked, resulting in crunchier texture and often richer aromas that dogs love.
-
Canning – Wet dog food is typically canned, which preserves moisture and creates intense, meaty flavors many dogs find irresistible.
-
Freeze-drying – This newer method preserves most of the food’s nutrients and natural flavors, creating highly palatable products.
My Charlie always goes crazy for his freeze-dried treats. They must taste amazing to him because he’ll do practically any trick to get one!
Flavor Enhancers: The Secret Ingredients
Many dog foods contain flavor enhancers to make them more appealing. These include:
- Animal digest – A concentrated liquid or powder from enzymatically broken down animal tissues that adds a rich, meaty taste
- Fish oil – Not only healthy (rich in omega-3s) but adds flavor dogs love
- Natural flavors – Derived from essential oils, extracts, or hydrolysates of plant/animal sources
- Synthetic flavors – Artificial flavoring agents like MSG (though these are generally less desirable)
While most commercial enhancers are safe, I personally try to stick with foods that use natural flavor enhancers rather than artificial ones for Charlie’s diet.
Finding the Right Food: How to Cater to Your Dog’s Taste Preferences
Every dog has unique preferences, just like people! Here’s how to find what your pup loves:
-
Experiment with different protein sources – Try chicken, beef, fish, or lamb to see which one gets the most enthusiastic response.
-
Mix textures – Some dogs prefer wet food, others like dry kibble, and many love a combination of both.
-
Pay attention to their eating habits – If your dog leaves food in the bowl or eats reluctantly, they might not be enjoying the flavor.
When I first brought Charlie home, he seemed totally uninterested in the kibble my older dog Sam was eating. After trying a few different options, I discovered he absolutely loves Wellness CORE Grain-Free Wet Dog Food. His whole demeanor changes when I open a can!
Common Questions About Dog Food Taste
Can I add flavor enhancers to my dog’s food?
Yes, you can add safe flavor enhancers like a spoonful of wet food, a little low-sodium broth, or a sprinkle of freeze-dried meat toppers. Just be sure to check with your vet first, especially if your dog has specific dietary needs.
How can I determine my dog’s taste preferences?
The best approach is trial and error. Offer different flavors and textures and watch how enthusiastically they eat each option. Dogs vote with their appetites!
Is it safe for my dog to eat different flavors of kibble?
Absolutely! As long as the food meets their nutritional needs and doesn’t cause digestive issues, variety can actually be beneficial. Just transition between foods gradually to avoid upset tummies.
Can a dog’s taste preferences change over time?
Yes, just like humans, dogs can develop new preferences as they age. Factors like health conditions, medication, and even environmental changes can affect what flavors appeal to them.
The Human “Kibble” Comparison
Interestingly, there are some foods that function basically as “human kibble” – complete nutrition in a convenient form. Things like meal replacement shakes or nutrition bars contain all the basic ingredients, vitamins, and minerals humans need. But even these are designed specifically for human palates and are nothing like actual dog kibble.
Should You Ever Taste Your Dog’s Food?
While there’s nothing dangerous about tasting your dog’s food (assuming you’re healthy and the food is fresh), it’s important to remember that it’s formulated for canine taste buds and nutritional needs, not human ones.
If curiosity gets the better of you like it did me, just be prepared for disappointment – what tastes amazing to your pup probably won’t impress your human palate!
My Final Thoughts
After researching dog food flavors and observing my own dogs’ preferences over the years, I’ve realized that the most important thing isn’t whether I would enjoy their food, but whether they do. The enthusiastic tail wags and empty bowls tell me everything I need to know about how my dogs’ food tastes to them.
When choosing food for your furry friend, focus on quality ingredients that provide proper nutrition rather than what you think might taste good. Your dog’s excited dance at mealtime will be the ultimate test of whether you’ve found a winner!
Remember, our dogs experience taste differently than we do, so judging their food by human standards just doesn’t make sense. What matters most is finding a nutritious option that makes your pup happy and healthy.

Cesar Naturally Crafted Australian Turkey
I have to say that the design of the can screamed “premium”, from the label with the Japanese words (even though it’s made in Australia) to the polished gold hue of the can itself. We could see chunks of what looked like vegetables, so that was cool.
Smell: As if it had been seasoned with spices, there was a smoky scent to the meat paste. Fancy.
Taste: Tasted like an unsalted meat stew, which is not entirely unpleasant, and weirdly, both our editor and I tasted black pepper. It was such a step up from the cat food that I questioned whether I was a dog food person, and our editor replied:
Price: RM4.30
Verdict: A solid ★★★★★★★★★☆
Pedigree Puppy Chicken Flavor in Gravy
Smell: The packaging gave us a bit of PTSD cuz it’s similar to the cat food ones. To my relief, it smelled like luncheon meat.
Taste: We once again tasted pepper somewhere in the meat and gravy, prompting us to check the packaging to see if pepper was listed as one of the ingredients. Nope, but it did say that it contained “herbs”, so we’ll go ahead and say maybe. This one did not taste as good as the Cesar, but overall, not bad.
Price: RM2.70
Verdict: ★★★★★★★☆☆☆